Right to Try 2.0 ... would provide access to individualized, rare disease and one-patient therapies
Create a Right to Try pathway for patients with life-threatening or severely debilitating conditions to access individualized, one-patient therapies not eligible for FDA approval under the current regulatory system.
Occurrences
Evidence
FDA says Right to Try is for patients diagnosed with life-threatening diseases or conditions who have exhausted approved treatment options and cannot participate in a clinical trial. Eligible drugs must have completed Phase 1, be unapproved for any use, have an FDA application filed or be in a clinical trial intended to support approval, and be in active development. FDA says sponsors are not required to provide access.
Public Law 115-176 amended the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act to create section 561B for investigational drugs used by eligible patients. It defines eligible patients as having life-threatening disease or condition, exhausted approved options, and being unable to participate in a clinical trial. Eligible investigational drugs must have completed Phase 1 and either have an application filed or be under investigation in a clinical trial intended to support approval/licensure.
FDA reports Right to Try Act use for 2018-2022, 2023, and 2024. The table lists 12 eligible drugs or biological products for 2018-2022, 4 for 2023, and 5 for 2024 in the category where clinical outcomes data were not used in review of a marketing application.
The Washington Post reported that, during a dispute over FDA pressure on Sarepta Therapeutics to pause gene-therapy shipments, Sen. Ron Johnson said he relayed concerns to HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., FDA Commissioner Marty Makary, and President Trump. Johnson called it a right-to-try issue and said families were willing to assume the risks of these therapies.
Assessments
Johnson materially advanced federal Right to Try legislation, and the 2018 law created a pathway for eligible patients with life-threatening diseases to access certain investigational drugs outside standard FDA approval. But the enacted pathway is narrower than the promise: it does not generally cover severely debilitating conditions or individualized one-patient therapies that are not eligible for FDA approval under the current regulatory system, because eligible products must have completed Phase 1 and remain in approval-oriented active development. Later advocacy on access disputes shows continued effort but not creation of the promised broader pathway.