We must repeal this bad piece of legislation and replace it with reforms that will expand coverage while lowering costs.
Work to repeal the health care law and replace it with reforms that expand coverage while lowering costs.
Occurrences
Evidence
Congressman Sam Graves and Congresswoman Nikki Budzinski reintroduced the bipartisan Save America’s Rural Hospitals Act to help struggling rural hospitals stay open and continue serving their communities. Graves said he was proud to reintroduce the bipartisan bill to make commonsense reforms, keep rural hospitals open, and ensure folks can get the care they need without having to drive hours to find it. The bill would eliminate Medicare sequestration for rural hospitals, make Medicare telehealth service enhancements permanent for Federally Qualified Health Centers and Rural Health Clinics, and make permanent increased Medicare payments for rural ground ambulance services.
Congress.gov records H.R.596 as passed by the House on February 3, 2015, but its status remained Passed House, not enacted into law. The CRS summary says the bill would repeal the ACA and directed committees to report replacement-style provisions including lower premiums and increasing insured Americans.
The House roll-call page for H.R.596, Roll Call 58, records passage 239-186 and lists Rep. Sam Graves of Missouri as voting Yea.
Congress.gov lists H.R.3762 as passed by the House and Senate, presented to the President, vetoed on January 8, 2016, and failed to pass over veto on February 2, 2016. The summary shows repeal of ACA subsidies, penalties, Medicaid expansion, and related taxes.
Congress.gov records H.R.1628 as the American Health Care Act of 2017, passed by the House 217-213 on May 4, 2017, with final status Passed House. The bill amended the ACA, ended Medicaid expansion for new enrollees after 2019, and altered subsidies, cost sharing, essential-benefit waivers, and tax provisions.
The House roll-call page for H.R.1628, Roll Call 256, records passage 217-213 and lists Rep. Sam Graves of Missouri as voting Yea.
CBO and JCT estimated that the House-passed AHCA would reduce deficits by $119 billion but increase the uninsured population by 23 million in 2026 relative to current law.
The Senate roll-call page for amendment 667 to H.R.1628 records Vote Result: Amendment Rejected, with 49 yeas and 51 nays on July 28, 2017.
HHS describes the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act as the comprehensive health care reform law enacted in March 2010, with ongoing goals to make affordable insurance available, expand Medicaid, and lower health care costs generally.
HealthCare.gov says Marketplace plans must cover treatment for pre-existing conditions and cannot reject, charge more, or refuse essential-benefit payment based on prior conditions.
Assessments
The promised outcome was not delivered: the Affordable Care Act was not repealed and replaced with reforms that both expanded coverage and lowered costs. Graves did take serious legislative action toward repeal-and-replace, including voting for House ACA repeal efforts such as H.R.596 and H.R.1628, and supporting later health-care access measures. But those repeal-and-replace bills did not become law, the 2017 Senate effort failed, and CBO projected the major House-passed AHCA would increase the uninsured population rather than expand coverage. Because there was substantial effort but no enacted fulfillment of the promised outcome, this counts as never delivered with an effort badge.
The promised outcome was to work to repeal the federal health care law and replace it with reforms expanding coverage while lowering costs. The ACA was not repealed or replaced, so the substantive promised outcome was not delivered. Graves did materially support repeal-and-replace efforts while in federal office, including Republican repeal efforts, and the provided evidence shows continued health-care reform activity, but those actions did not achieve ACA repeal and replacement. The later rural hospital bill is related health-care policy, not fulfillment of the specific repeal-and-replace promise.