Call for the closure of all private detention facilities.

Andy Kim · New Jersey · Democratic

policy impact 5.00 specificity 1.00 extraction confidence 96%

Contest this claim

Occurrences

Evidence

U.S. Sen. Andy Kim grilled a fellow senator and nominee to be the next Department of Homeland Security secretary Wednesday about a warehouse the department purchased in Roxbury to house immigrant detainees. Kim, a Democrat, asked Sen. Markwayne Mullin, an Oklahoma Republican, during Mullin’s confirmation hearing before the Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs whether it is fair for the department to open 'large-scale detention facilities' without local input. Roxbury officials have opposed the warehouse purchase and said they were not consulted about it.

Senator Andy Kim questioned DHS nominee Markwayne Mullin about the establishment of a large-scale immigrant detention facility in Roxbury without local consultation.

partial same_term A for effort

Sen. Andy Kim questions nominee about proposed Roxbury ICE facility
secondary · model gpt-4.1 · confidence 90%

Contest this evidence item

Senator Andy Kim joined his fellow Democrats on the Senate Homeland Security & Governmental Affairs Committee in demanding answers over reports that former Department of Homeland Security (DHS) advisor Corey Lewandowski solicited personal payments from companies in exchange for government contracts. In a series of letters sent to DHS and contractors GEO Group and Salus Worldwide Solutions, the senators raised concerns that Lewandowski’s alleged conduct may violate federal bribery and ethics laws.

Senator Andy Kim co-signed letters demanding investigations into alleged unethical practices involving private detention facility contracts.

partial same_term A for effort

Kim Joins Homeland Security Committee Democrats in Demanding Answers on Corey Lewandowski’s Alleged 'Pay-to-Play' Scheme at DHS
secondary · model gpt-4.1 · confidence 80%

Contest this evidence item

On June 4, 2026, the Senate rejected the motion to waive budgetary discipline for Kim Amendment No. 5545, which would have provided appropriations for inspections of the Delaney Hall Detention Facility.

A Senate procedural vote to advance Kim's Delaney Hall inspection amendment failed, showing continued effort but no closure of private detention facilities.

never same_term A for effort

U.S. Senate Roll Call Votes 119th Congress - 2nd Session
secondary · model gpt-5.4-mini · confidence 97%

Contest this evidence item

The vote concerned Kim Amendment No. 5545 to fund inspections of Delaney Hall; the motion was rejected 46-53, and Kim voted yea.

Kim advanced a concrete oversight amendment for Delaney Hall, a private ICE detention facility, but the Senate motion failed and did not close private detention facilities.

never same_term A for effort

U.S. Senate Roll Call Votes 119th Congress - 2nd Session
secondary · model gpt-5.5 · confidence 98%

Contest this evidence item

Kim joined committee Democrats seeking answers about alleged pay-to-play involving GEO Group, described as a major private prison company running DHS detention facilities.

The official release shows Kim pursued oversight of private detention contracting, but it was investigatory and did not close all private detention facilities.

partial same_term A for effort

Kim Joins Homeland Security Committee Democrats in Demanding Answers on Corey Lewandowski’s Alleged 'Pay-to-Play' Scheme at DHS
secondary · model gpt-5.5 · confidence 93%

Contest this evidence item

AP reported Delaney Hall opened May 1 as a 1,000-bed facility operated by a private prison company after ICE and GEO Group reached a $1 billion, 15-year deal.

A private immigration detention facility opened during Kim’s Senate term, directly showing the promised nationwide closure had not occurred.

never same_term

What to know about the newly opened immigration detention center in New Jersey's biggest city
secondary · model gpt-5.5 · confidence 94%

Contest this evidence item

The Guardian reported Kim visited Delaney Hall, tried to de-escalate outside, was pepper-sprayed, and said the way to fix the facility was to shut it down.

Kim publicly called for shutting down Delaney Hall and engaged in on-site oversight, but this did not amount to closure of all private detention facilities.

partial same_term A for effort

US senator says he was pepper-sprayed by federal agents during protest at ICE facility
secondary · model gpt-5.5 · confidence 91%

Contest this evidence item

The Guardian reported Delaney Hall remained an ICE jail operated by GEO Group under a $1 billion, 15-year contract, with families and detainees alleging continuing problems.

After Kim’s shutdown call and oversight efforts, Delaney Hall was still operating as a private ICE detention facility, supporting a non-delivery finding.

never same_term

‘It’s like they’re kidnapped there’: families tell of distress over ‘inhumane’ ICE jail
secondary · model gpt-5.5 · confidence 92%

Contest this evidence item

Executive Order 14148 lists EO 14006, the prior order restricting DOJ private criminal detention contracts, among revoked executive actions.

Federal executive policy moved away from even the narrower DOJ private-prison restriction during Kim’s Senate term; no federal action closed all private detention facilities.

never same_term

Initial Rescissions of Harmful Executive Orders and Actions
secondary · model gpt-5.5 · confidence 90%

Contest this evidence item

Assessments

never same_term A for effort

Andy Kim repeatedly opposed private detention facilities and advanced oversight efforts, including questioning DHS nominees and pushing an amendment tied to inspections, but the record provided shows no closure of all private detention facilities. The available evidence supports a serious same-term effort that fell short of the promised outcome.

provider codex_cli · model gpt-5.4-mini · confidence 97%

never same_term A for effort

The evidence shows that Senator Andy Kim took actions such as co-signing investigation letters and publicly questioning a DHS nominee about private detention facilities. However, these actions fall short of achieving the specific promise to close all private detention facilities, as there is no documentation of legislative passage, executive action, or closure of such facilities. He made serious attempts within his capacity, but the promised outcome was not delivered.

provider openai · model gpt-4.1 · confidence 90%