I write today to strongly urge the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) to issue an Emergency Airworthiness Directive (EAD) to permanently ground the McDonnell Douglas MD-11 from service
Urge the FAA to issue an Emergency Airworthiness Directive to permanently ground the McDonnell Douglas MD-11 from service.
Occurrences
sent a letter to the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), urging the agency to permanently ground the McDonnell Douglas MD-11 (MD-11) after the devastating crash of UPS Flight 2976 in Louisville last November.
Evidence
FAA Emergency Airworthiness Directive 2025-23-51 for MD-11 aircraft required inspections and applicable corrective actions before further flight; the cited action was not a permanent retirement or permanent grounding order.
The NTSB page says UPS Flight 2976 was a Boeing/McDonnell-Douglas MD-11F destroyed shortly after takeoff in Louisville on November 4, 2025, and lists the FAA as a party to the investigation.
The NTSB update says the left engine and pylon separated shortly after rotation and that investigators were reviewing Boeing and FAA correspondence related to the MD-11 service letter and bearing issue.
WSJ reported FedEx was preparing to return MD-11 cargo jets to service in May while awaiting the final FAA-approved procedure, after regulators grounded all MD-11s following the UPS crash.
Reuters reported that FedEx resumed MD-11 cargo flights after the FAA lifted the grounding order.
WSJ reported UPS completed the retirement of its MD-11 fleet and took a $137 million write-off tied to that retirement after the crash.
CNN reported McGarvey emphasized that the NTSB would investigate the crash thoroughly. Available reporting located for this assessment did not show him urging FAA to issue a permanent MD-11 grounding directive.
Assessments
The available record shows the FAA issued only a temporary Emergency Airworthiness Directive requiring MD-11 inspections and corrective actions before further flight, not a permanent grounding from service. Later reporting indicates the FAA lifted the grounding and FedEx resumed MD-11 operations, while UPS voluntarily retired its own MD-11 fleet. The evidence also does not show McGarvey specifically urging the FAA to issue a permanent MD-11 grounding directive, only public comments about the crash investigation. Because neither the promised advocacy nor the permanent FAA outcome is documented, the promise was not delivered.