Her new legislation would halt the Administration’s proposal in its tracks, preventing the White House from implementing the rule. This legislation would protect independent and merit-based grantmaking, ensuring taxpayer funds are awarded based on expertise and technical merit rather than Trump’s political whims.
She will block efforts to politicize federal grants and preserve independent, merit-based grantmaking.
Occurrences
Evidence
Congress.gov lists Rep. Haley M. Stevens [D-MI-11] as an original cosponsor of H.R.1709, the Scientific Integrity Act, with a cosponsor date of 03/13/2019.
Congress.gov says H.R.1709 would prohibit covered federal agency employees and contractors from scientific or research misconduct or manipulating scientific or technical findings, and require agencies to develop, adopt, and enforce scientific integrity policies. The bill status remained Introduced; latest action was ordered reported by committee on 10/17/2019.
The Clerk records Roll Call 404 on H.R.4346 as Passed, 243-187, and lists Stevens, Democratic, Michigan, as voting Yea.
Congress.gov shows H.R.4346 became Public Law No. 117-167 on 08/09/2022 and states that the act authorizes programs and activities of the federal science agencies.
The enacted CHIPS and Science Act text requires multiple awards to use competitive, merit-review or merit-based processes, including NSF and regional innovation programs, and creates NSF research security functions to address risks to research integrity and foreign interference.
Assessments
Stevens took concrete federal legislative action toward the promise by originally cosponsoring the Scientific Integrity Act in 2019, which targeted political manipulation of scientific work but did not become law. She later voted for the CHIPS and Science Act, enacted in 2022, which included merit-review and merit-based grantmaking requirements for several federal science and innovation programs. That preserves independent grantmaking in relevant science-agency contexts, but it is not a comprehensive block on politicized federal grants across the federal government, so the promise is only partially fulfilled. The enacted component occurred in a later congressional term.