Secure our border permanently instead of just having it depend on the current President. Reform our immigration system.
Work to secure the border permanently and reform the immigration system so it does not depend on the current president.
Occurrences
Evidence
On passage of S. 744, the comprehensive immigration reform bill, Deb Fischer (R-NE) voted Nay.
Biden's June 4, 2024 proclamation used executive action to restrict the Mexico-United States border and limit asylum processing.
On passage of S. 5, the Laken Riley Act, Deb Fischer voted Yea.
In the lookback window, the Senate voted on proceeding to S.J.Res.190, a disapproval resolution for an Executive Office for Immigration Review rule on Board of Immigration Appeals appellate procedures. The motion to proceed was rejected, 46-48; Fischer voted Nay.
The Senate roll call for H.R.1 shows the bill passed 50-50 with the Vice President voting Yea. Fischer is listed as Yea.
The enacted H.R.1 text appropriates $46.55 billion for border infrastructure and wall systems, $45 billion for ICE detention capacity, $29.85 billion for ICE enforcement operations, and $3.33 billion for DOJ immigration judge and related staffing.
Congress.gov shows S.5 became Public Law 119-1. The public law amended the INA to require custody and detainers for certain inadmissible aliens charged with or convicted of specified crimes, and created state enforcement standing provisions.
President Trump’s executive order set border policy by directing wall construction, detention to the fullest extent permitted by law, resumption of Migrant Protection Protocols, termination of CBP One parole use, and other agency actions.
The Federal Register published President Biden’s Proclamation 10773, which suspended and limited entry across the southern border when encounter thresholds were met. The proclamation also stated that executive action could not deliver the major policy reforms and resources in the bipartisan legislative proposal.
Assessments
Fischer did not deliver the full promised outcome of permanently securing the border and reforming immigration so it no longer depended on presidential policy. Border management remained heavily shaped by executive actions in 2024 and 2025, and the broad 2013 comprehensive reform bill did not become law, with Fischer voting against it. However, she later voted for enacted immigration and border-enforcement measures, including the Laken Riley Act and H.R.1, which funded major border infrastructure, detention, enforcement, and immigration-court capacity. Those laws materially advanced enforcement goals but fall short of permanent comprehensive reform independent of the current president.
Fischer took some concrete action consistent with the promise, most notably voting for the 2025 Laken Riley Act, which supports stronger border enforcement. But the broader promised result was not achieved: there was no permanent immigration-system reform that removed dependence on presidential action, and border policy was still being shaped by executive action in 2024. Her 2013 vote against S. 744 also cuts against credit for delivering broad immigration reform. That record supports partial credit for later-term effort, not full delivery.