I'm pleased to reintroduce my bipartisan MVP Act to expand access to innovative, lifesaving treatments for vulnerable Americans with rare diseases. This transformative legislation would give states the flexibility to offer high-cost therapies for rare diseases without raising taxes or cutting other state programs.
Brett Guthrie will expand access to innovative, lifesaving treatments for vulnerable Americans with rare diseases by advancing the Medicaid VBPs for Patients Act and value-based Medicaid purchasing agreements.
Occurrences
Evidence
CMS finalized a rule to support state flexibility to enter value-based purchasing arrangements with manufacturers, including Medicaid, effective March 1, 2021 with some provisions effective January 1, 2022.
Current regulation defines a value-based purchasing arrangement as one intended to align pricing or payments to observed or expected therapeutic or clinical value, including evidence-based or outcomes-based measures.
Current regulation states that if a manufacturer offers a VBP arrangement to all states, best price may include varying best price points for a single dosage form and strength because of that arrangement.
Congress.gov lists Brett Guthrie as Representative for Kentucky District 2 in the 111th-119th Congresses and shows his sponsored legislation and member activity records.
H.R.1 became Public Law 119-21 on July 4, 2025. Its health title includes extensive Medicaid provisions such as eligibility redeterminations, provider tax limits, work requirements, cost sharing, HCBS waivers, and rural health funding; the page contains no matching text for value-based purchasing.
The House vote on concurring in the Senate amendment to H.R.1 passed 218-214. Brett Guthrie, Republican of Kentucky, voted Aye.
Assessments
Current CMS Medicaid drug rebate regulations do support value-based purchasing arrangements and allow multiple best-price points when manufacturers offer VBP arrangements to all states, so the underlying Medicaid VBP policy mechanism exists. However, the evidence does not show that Brett Guthrie sponsored, wrote, enacted, or materially advanced a Medicaid VBPs for Patients Act, and the major 119th Congress Medicaid law cited did not include the promised VBP rare-disease policy. Because the policy exists through CMS rulemaking rather than demonstrated Guthrie delivery of the named promise, this merits partial credit rather than full delivery.